• Sergei Eisenstein’s “Confusion of Feelings”: Overcoming Apprenticeship Though the Biography of the Teacher

УДК: 791.44.071.1+792.075

DOI: 10.35852/2588-0144-2024-3-75-94

EDN: MFVHHF

Full text (PDF): Download

Natalie S. Ryabchikova

PhD in Film Studies, lecturer at the School of Design
Higher School of Economics
Moscow, Russia
E-mail: natalia.ryabchikova@gmail.com

Sergei Eisenstein’s “Confusion of Feelings”: Overcoming Apprenticeship Though the Biography of the Teacher

Abstract

The article examines the relationship between two innovators of 20th-century theatre and cinema — Vsevolod Meyerhold and Sergei Eisenstein — and more specifically, how this relationship is refracted through Eisenstein’s texts (and imagination). Meyerhold, as Eisenstein’s mentor, serves as a key element in Eisenstein’s model of understanding his own development and identity as a creator. However, this understanding is not direct but is conveyed through a series of reflections, refractions, and metaphors: Saturn devouring his children; Freud pushing away his students; Anatole France and his biographer Jean-Jacques Brousson; and the heroes of Stefan Zweig’s novella Confusion of Feelings (Verwirrung der Gefühle, published in English as Confusion). Eisenstein employs the model of “a student rejected by the teacher surpasses him” to describe the relationships between Meyerhold and Stanislavsky, as well as between himself and Meyerhold, thereby placing himself in a direct line of creative heritage. The article also explores the theme of a student writing a teacher's biography as a form of acquiring mastery, and Eisenstein’s transition, in his own understanding, from the role of a biographer to that of a subject of biography (and autobiography). Meyerhold’s biography provides Eisenstein with keys to narrativizing the pivotal moments of his own life and career. Notably, the figure of Eisenstein’s father, Mikhail Osipovich, appears and disappears in various “plots” of the film director’s biography, depending on what the biographer chooses to emphasize. Ultimately, in Eisenstein’s own memoirs, his father finds a place within the narrative model derived from Meyerhold’s biography, written by Nikolai Volkov, who has nearly Eisenstein’s biographer.

Keywords

Sergei Eisenstein, Vsevolod Meyerhold, biography, autobiography, Stefan Zweig, Jean-Jacques Brousson, Ivan Aksenov.

For citation

Ryabchikova N.S. Sergei Eisenstein’s “Confusion of Feelings”: Overcoming Apprenticeship Though the Biography of the Teacher. Theatre. Fine Arts. Cinema. Music. 2024, no. 3, pp. 75–94.

DOI: 10.35852/2588-0144-2024-3-75-94

EDN MFVHHF

References

  1. Zabrodin V.V. Eisenshtein: popytka teatra: Stat‘i. Publikatsii [Eisenstein: An Attempt at Theatre: Articles. Publications]. Moscow: Eizenshtein-tsentr, 2005. 343 p. 
  2. Eizenshtein o Meyerholde, 1919–1948 [Eisenstein on Meyerhold, 1919–1948]. Ed. by V. Zabrodin. Moscow: Novoe izdatelstvo, 2005. 352 p. 
  3. Kozlov L. Gipoteza o nevyskazannom posviashchenii [The Hypothesis of the Hidden Dedication]. In: Voprosy kinoiskusstva [Problems of Film Art]. Vol. 10. Moscow: Nauka, 1970, pp. 109–133. 
  4. Roshal’ L.M. Gore umu, ili Eizenshtein i Meyerhold: dvoinoj portret na fone epokhi [Woe to Wit, or Eisenstein and Meyerhold: A Double Portrait against the Background of an Era]. Moscow: Materik, 2007. 392 p. 
  5. Kak stat’ Eizenshteinom. Kratkij kurs [How to Become Eisenstein. A Crash Course]. Ed.N. Ryabchikova. Saint Petersburg; Moscow: Podpisnye izdania: Iskusstvokino, 2022. 400 p. 
  6. Eizenshtein S.M. Memuary: V 2 t. T. 2. Istinnye puti izobreteniia. Profili [Memoirs: In 2 vols. Vol. 2. True Paths of Invention. Profiles]. Moscow: Redaktsiia gazety “Trud”: Muzei kino, 1998. 544 p. 
  7. Zabrodin V. Opyty konkretnogo kinovedeniia [Experiments in Practical Film Studies]. Moscow: VGIK, 2013. 143 p.
  8. Zabrodin V. Eizenshtein: kino, vlast’, zhenshchiny [Eisenstein: Cinema, Power, Women]. Moscow: Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie, 2011. 560 p. 
  9. Eizenshtein S.M. Memuary: V 2 t. T. 1. Wie sag’ ich meinem Kinde?! [Memoirs: In 2 vols. Vol. 1. Wie sag’ ich meinem Kinde?!]. Moscow: Redaktsiya gazety “Trud”: Muzei kino, 1998. 432 p. 
  10. Bulgakowa O. Eisenstein und Deutschland. Texte. Dokumente. Briefe [Eisenstein and Germany: Texts. Documents. Letters]. Berlin: Akademie der Künste, 1998. 240 s. 
  11. Eizenshtein S.M. Montazh [Montage]. Moscow: Muzei kino, 2000. 592 p.
  12.  Eisenstein S. Immoral Memories: An Autobiography. Trans. by Herbert Marshall. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Co., 1983. 292 p. 
  13. Volkov N.D. Teatralnye vechera [Theatre Evenings]. Moscow: Iskusstvo, 1966. 478 p. 
  14. Aksenov I.A. Sergei Eizenshtein: portret khudozhnika [Sergei Eisenstein: Portrait of an Artist]. Moscow: Soyuz kinematografistov SSSR: Vsesoiuznoe tvorchesko-proizvodstvennoe objedinenie “Kinotsentr”, 1991. 128 p. 
  15. Seton M. Sergei Eisenstein: The definitive biography. London: The Bodley Head, 1952. 533 p. 
  16. Bulgakova O. Aksenov, Eizenshtein, ili Kto byl ten‘iu ottsa Gamleta [Aksenov, Eisenstein, or Who Was the Ghost of Hamlet’s Father]. In: Aksenov and the Environs. Ed. by Lars Kleberg and Aleksei Semenenko. Huddinga: Södertörn högskola, 2012, pp. 173–194. 
  17. Volkov N.D. Meierkhol‘d: V 2 t. T. 1: 1874–1908 [Meyerhold. In Two Vols. Vol. 1: 1874–1908]. Moscow; Leningrad: Akademia, 1929. 407 p. 
  18. Rostotskii S. Na ulitse Eizenshteina [On Eisenstein Street]. In: Eizenshtein v vospominanijakh sovremennikov [Eisenstein Remembered by His Contemporaries]. Moscow: Iskusstvo, 1974, pp. 284–302. 
  19. Vogman E. Eisenstein’s Capital Diaries: An Introduction. In: October. 2024, no. 188 (Spring), pp. 3–20.

Received: 01.07.2024

Revised: 26.07.2024

Accepted: 29.07.2024